Moderated Usability Testing: Process and Best Practices

Usability testing assists you in gathering qualitative data to gain a deeper understanding of your users. To maximize the benefits of your usability testing, you need to identify the testing method that best suits your project. Choosing for moderated usability testing proves dependable in ensuring that your digital products and interfaces meet user desires and expectations.

Moderated testing involves a proficient moderator who meticulously directs test participants, observes their actions, and gathers priceless insights throughout the testing sessions.

In this blog, we will learn about moderated testing, explore its process and best practices, and demonstrate how it can be a game-changer in user experience research.

What is Moderated Usability Testing?

Moderated usability testing is a technique used in user experience (UX) research to evaluate a product’s or interface’s usability and user-friendliness. In this usability test, a researcher or moderator guides participants through a set of activities while observing and collecting data on their interactions, feedback, and overall user experience.

Moderated testing is also known as Live Conversations at user testing. Facilitators for moderated tests need to be experts in the product being tested. They are responsible for giving tasks, guiding test participants, taking notes on what participants do and say, answering questions, and listening to their real-time feedback during the test.

Moderated usability testing can be done in person or remotely. When it’s done online, participants need to show their screens to the facilitator so they can do the test together in real time. Participants are often encouraged to discuss their thoughts as they do the tasks. This helps the facilitator understand how they go from one point to another.

When to Choose Moderated Usability Testing?

Moderated usability testing is usually used earlier in the design process than unmoderated usability testing. That’s because it allows the UX teams to ask participants more questions about their answers. This is really important when figuring out the main idea for a design project.

Moderated testing can provide valuable insights if your product is complex, has a specialized audience, or involves intricate tasks. The moderator can offer guidance and context that helps test participants navigate these complexities. Participants can express their thought processes and discussions and provide a thorough comprehension of their experiences.

When your project involves sensitive information, proprietary technology, or confidentiality concerns, this usability testing allows you to monitor and control the test environment closely. It helps you to get feedback from diverse demographic groups for a complete product review.

Choose moderated testing if you want to seek comprehensive insights, leverage real-time user input, and possess the necessary resources to conduct the tests efficiently. This approach proves particularly valuable during the initial stages of product development and when dealing with intricate or specialized user experiences.

Moderated Usability Testing Process

Moderated testing is a structured and insightful approach to understanding how users interact with your product or system. Here is a step-by-step process to conduct moderated usability testing:

Step 1: Planning and Preparation

Planning and preparing the details of the usability testing session is the most crucial part of the entire process. This initial step sets the tone for the entire process. Here’s what you need to do:

Determine Your Research’s Nature

First, you must clearly define the scope and objectives of your usability testing. Identify the specific areas of your product or website you want to assess. What issues or aspects are you targeting?

Choose the Right Users

Select the user personas you wish to test. These users should ideally represent your target audience. Decide whether you want to focus on a particular user segment, like those who have recently purchased on your e-commerce website.

Logistical Planning

Determine where your testing will take place – whether in your office, a usability lab, or remotely over the internet. Create a clear timetable for your sessions, especially if you’re booking a lab. Think about who will moderate the sessions. If you’re taking on this role, ensure you have the necessary skills. Alternatively, you may hire trained moderators.

Setting up Recording

If you decide to record the testing sessions, plan the recording setup. Recording lets you review the sessions later and capture details the moderator may miss. A controlled lab atmosphere makes recording participants’ screens, spoken comments, and body language easier.

Step 2: Participant Recruitment

The success of moderated usability testing depends on recruiting the right participants. The methods for test participant recruitment can vary, but here’s what you should consider:

• Hire an Agency: When you’re looking for specific or hard-to-reach user demographics, collaborating with specialized recruitment agencies is often the most efficient. These agencies have the resources to identify and recruit suitable participants.
• Utilize Your Website: If you already have an established user base, consider using your website to recruit participants. Techniques like pop-up polls can help you identify willing participants.
• Harness Social Media: Use your social media presence to reach out to potential participants. Engage with your followers and seek volunteers from your online community.
• Involve Your Clients: Reach out directly to your clients or customers and ask if they’d be willing to participate. Participants are often flattered to be asked for their opinions and are curious about how their insights can improve your product.

Step 3: Task Design

Designing the testing tasks is a pivotal step in moderated testing. It involves creating scenarios and specific tasks that participants will undertake during the testing session. Here’s what you need to consider when designing tasks:

Develop Scenarios

Create scenarios that provide context for the testing tasks. These scenarios should reflect real-world user situations.

For example, if you’re designing a fitness app, you could create a scenario like this: “You’ve decided to start a new fitness routine, and you’re looking for an app to help you track your workouts and set fitness goals. How would you find the right app for your needs?” These scenarios direct participants to perform tasks that assess their ability to search for fitness apps, compare features, and select the most suitable option.

Avoid Excessive Specificity

While scenarios should captivate participants, it’s best to avoid making them overly detailed. For example, requesting participants to choose a specific brand of running shoes might not be relevant if they prefer cycling.

Highlight Vital Functions

Make sure your scenarios concentrate on the most crucial functions of your website or product. In the context of a travel booking platform, this might mean crafting scenarios that guide users through booking flights and accommodations. Offering participants a limited budget to work with during the test can result in more meaningful and practical assessments.

Step 4: Moderator’s Role

The role of the moderator in moderated usability testing is pivotal. A skilled moderator plays a crucial part in ensuring the success of the testing session. Here’s what you need to do:

• Introductions and Warm-Up: Establish a comfortable environment for the test participants, ensuring they are physically comfortable and understand the session’s proceedings. If you’re recording the session, ask for their permission. Build rapport by asking friendly questions, such as how far they’ve traveled to get to the testing location or if they’ve done user testing before.
• Collect Pre-Testing Data: Gather demographic and psychographic information from participants before testing. For example, inquire about their online shopping habits, frequency of online purchases, methods of product discovery, and factors influencing their buying decisions.
• Transition to Tasks: Use the rapport you’ve built to transition participants into the first testing task. The order of tasks can be adjusted based on the participant’s mood and skill level.
• Taking Notes: Observe and record participants’ actions and comments during testing. In an ideal situation, a second person may handle note-taking, allowing you to focus strongly on the participant.
• Follow-Up Questions and Wrap-Up: At the end of the session, provide an opportunity for follow-up questions and collect the participant’s final feedback. Express gratitude for their participation.

Data Collection Methods of Moderated Tests

Data collection involves gathering valuable insights from participants interacting with a product or system. Here are the primary data collection methods used during moderated tests:

• Observation: Moderated user testing helps identify subtle actions and responses through body language. As the moderator, you closely watch and observe participants as they navigate your product. Pay attention to their actions, interactions, and body language. This observational data helps identify usability issues and user preferences.
• Think-Aloud Protocol: Encourage participants to vocalize their thoughts and decision-making processes as they interact with your product. This method offers insights into their cognitive processes, shedding light on moments of frustration and clarity.
• Video and Audio Recording: Consider using video and audio recording equipment during sessions. Video recordings capture screen interactions, facial expressions, and body language, while audio recordings capture spoken comments and reactions. These recordings offer a comprehensive view of the testing process.
• Questionnaires and Surveys: You can conduct questionnaires or surveys to participants before or after the usability testing session. These structured tools gather feedback on specific aspects of your product and the overall user experience.
• Post-Test Interviews: Conduct debriefing sessions or interviews to gather additional qualitative insights after participants complete the tasks. Encourage participants to share their overall impressions, preferences, and suggestions for improvement.
• System Usability Scale (SUS): Use the SUS, a standardized questionnaire, to assess your product’s usability. Participants rate the system on a scale, providing quantitative data that can be compared across different usability tests.
• Eyetracking: In certain cases, use eye-tracking technology to record where participants look on the screen. This can help identify areas of the interface that attract or divert attention.

Advantages and Limitations of Moderated Usability Testing

Moderated testing is a valuable method for evaluating the user-friendliness of products and interfaces. While it offers several advantages, it also has certain limitations that must be considered. Here are some significant benefits and drawbacks of moderated usability testing.

Advantages of Moderated Testing

• In-Depth Insights: One of the primary advantages is the depth of insights it provides. Test facilitators can interact with participants, observe their behavior, and ask follow-up questions. This facilitates a deeper understanding of the user experience and any issues they may encounter.
• Real-Time Feedback: Moderated test allows for real-time feedback. Test facilitators can provide immediate clarification, address user questions, and gather feedback while the participant is actively using the product. This can lead to more comprehensive and accurate feedback.
• Customization: Test scenarios and tasks can be tailored to specific user groups or personas. This customization ensures that the testing process is relevant to the product’s target audience, resulting in feedback that closely aligns with actual user needs.
• Complex Scenarios: The moderated test is well-suited for assessing complex user experiences. It can simulate intricate use cases, such as multi-step processes or interactions with specialized features, helping to uncover issues that automated or unmoderated testing may miss.
• User Empathy: Test facilitators can empathize with users, understanding their frustrations, confusion, and emotions during the testing process. This qualitative data provides a richer context for interpreting usability problems and finding solutions.

Limitations of Moderated Testing

• Resource-Intensive: Moderated test demands more resources than some other testing methods. It requires a skilled moderator, a quiet testing environment, and the availability of participants. This can make it more time-consuming and costly.
• Small Sample Size: Moderated test typically involves a smaller sample size due to the time and resource requirements. While this can provide detailed insights, it may not represent the diversity of users in a larger audience.
• Potential for Bias: The presence of a moderator can introduce bias into the testing process. Participants might feel pressured to provide positive feedback, or the moderator’s expectations could inadvertently influence user behavior.
• Limited Scalability: Moderated tests are less scalable than unmoderated tests. It may not be suitable for testing products with a large user base or when quick, widespread feedback is needed.
• Scheduling Challenges: Coordinating schedules between participants, moderators, and testing facilities can be challenging, especially for remote moderated usability testing. Delays in scheduling can hinder the timely evaluation of a product.

Best Practices For Moderated Usability Testing

Moderated usability testing is valuable for gaining in-depth insights into the user experience. To ensure the effectiveness of your testing sessions, consider the following usability testing checklist or best practices:

1. Clear Objectives: Define specific testing objectives to ensure a focused usability evaluation.
2. Diverse Participants: Select participants that represent the diversity of your user base, encompassing different demographics, skills, and personas.
3. Realistic Scenarios: Create tasks and scenarios that closely mimic real-world user interactions with your product.
4. Moderator Training: Ensure moderators are trained in neutrality, effective communication, and facilitating usability testing sessions.
5. Pilot Testing: Before the official sessions, conduct pilot tests to identify and rectify any issues with tasks, scenarios, or the testing setup.
6. Comfortable Environment: Create a testing environment that is free from distractions and equipped with the necessary tools, such as computers and recording devices.
7. Open-Ended Questions: Pose open-ended questions to delve deeper into participant experiences, emotions, and preferences.
8. Time Management: Keep sessions on schedule by setting time limits for each task and gently guiding participants if they encounter difficulties.
9. Thorough Analysis: After the sessions, perform a systematic analysis of the collected data to identify patterns, usability issues, and areas for improvement.
10. Share Insights: Collaborate with the broader team, including designers, developers, and product managers, to implement improvements based on testing results.

Conclusion

Moderated usability testing is a potent tool for understanding and optimizing the user experience. It enables a direct and personal connection between testers and moderators, fostering a level of engagement that leads to candid feedback and a profound understanding of user behavior.

This usability testing method allows for the real-time capture of verbal responses and non-verbal cues, such as body language and facial expressions, providing a holistic view of the user’s journey. It empowers organizations to uncover usability issues, enhance the user experience, and drive product improvements.

QuestionPro Research Suite is a complete survey and research platform with many features and functionalities to help with moderated usability testing.

QuestionPro offers a user-friendly platform for creating surveys and questionnaires. This feature is invaluable for designing usability testing scenarios and question sets. You can easily create tasks that mirror real-world user interactions and capture feedback efficiently.

With QuestionPro, you can quickly see the data as people give their answers during usability tests. This helps moderators make necessary changes, solve user problems, and keep the testing going well.

If you still don’t know about our platform, you can make a free account to try out all the tools or request a free demo to talk to us about what your studio needs.

LEARN MORE       FREE TRIAL